Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rivets & Pins's avatar

I got a copy of this book (freebie, thankfully!) earlier this week and flicked through it to find the appalling choice of photos. As mentioned in an earlier comment here, P&S delegate responsibility for accuracy to the author. It'd be interesting to get his take on what on earth happened here.

I did some digging on the photos and as a result did a thread on the book on Twitter (under @rivetsandpins). As part of this, I discovered that photo no. 4 above (Hetzer) isn't even a photo from WW2. It's a re-enactment in Texas in 2009 with the running Hetzer from the Texas Military Forces Museum.

I've supplied feedback to P&S who have said they'll pass it on to the relevant person. Frankly, I don't expect any feedback from them.

If I'd paid £14.99 for the hard copy, I'd be furious. When you spot so many bad photos/captions just flicking through the book, you start to seriously doubt the accuracy of the text before you read it.

Expand full comment
Martin Cherrett's avatar

Well thanks to everyone here and the people who emailed me direct, including Quentin, Brad, Gary John and Robert. A few more complimentaries yet to be sent out for the most informed comments.

I think I can now summarise as follows:

1. Panzer IV Ausf. F2/G of the 4th Panzer Army passes by infantry near the Stalingrad-Morozosvk railway on the outskirts of Stalingrad, August 1942. So in all probability this is a dusting of concrete or similar from the smashed buildings in the city, not snow.

2. Panzergrenadier-SS Kampfgruppe Hansen in action during clashes in Poteau against Task Force Myers, 18 December 1944. Battle of the Bulge.

NB I have discovered Alamy are charging as much as a £179 to use this image … or you can get the free version from Wikimedia Commons.

3. An American car from the 26th Infantry Division of the US Army is driving past a Hetzer tank destroyer (Jagdpanzer 38(t)) destroyed on the road in the Saarlautern area (now Saarlouis). Number on the image suggests it was originally a US Army image.

4. The Jagdpanzer 38 (Sd.Kfz. 138/2), originally the leichter Panzerjäger 38(t), known mostly post-war as Hetzer, was a German light tank destroyer of the Second World War based on a modified Czechoslovakian Panzer 38(t) chassis. Starting from April 1944, about 2584 were built until the end of the war.

5. Platoon commander 5th company 112 5 Panzer Brigade (Panzer-Brigade 112) 47th Armoured Corps of the Wehrmacht confers with the commanders of the platoon tank Panzerkampfwagen IV (PzKpfw IV), commonly known as the Panzer IV, On the sleeve of the jacket of the platoon commander (Center) is located shield patch Crimea , turret machine gun MG 34/42 . Series of photographs was taken for propaganda purposes in the region of Lorraine France September 1944.

6. German soldiers near a Soviet IS-2 tank that was destroyed during a battle in Jelgava, a city in central Latvia. The IS-2 entered combat in World War II during the first months of 1944.

7. Dieppe, 19.8.1942, destroyed "Churchill" tank of the 14th Canadian Army Tank Regiment (Calgary Tanks),

As usual Pen & Sword get sent copies of my reviews ...

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts